Yoghurt is sold on reassurance. Much of the chiller is a pale run of tubs, the message being that nothing inside has turned. Sourmilk, a probiotic Greek-style yoghurt made in New York, arrived there with a name that describes milk that has.
Founded by Elan Halpern and Kiki Couchman, Sourmilk makes little attempt to blend in. Its vivid blue packaging carries a soft, white wordmark that looks as though it might have been written in yoghurt itself.
When I spoke to Halpern in April, for the inaugural edition of The Checkout, Sourmilk was still finding its way into New York's neighbourhood grocery stores. It had 9,669 Instagram followers.
Seven months later, that figure stands at 16,600. By June, Sourmilk had reached more than 100 stores. A request from one particularly enthusiastic customer even helped secure an order across all 17 Morton Williams locations.
The designer behind that unmistakable blue is Charlotte Cooper, founder of Charlotte Cooper Creative and former founding creative director of canned wine brand Bev. I spoke to Cooper about the peculiar challenge of making sour milk desirable, the thinking behind that blue and the unexpected pleasures of designing for the dairy aisle.
When Sourmilk came to you with the original brief, was there anything you ended up challenging?
Typically when founders come to me they don’t have official briefs, but they have big vision. When I first chatted with Kiki and Elan it was clear they had not only vision but big plans for their yogurt brand. It was like, "Yeah, we are gonna quit our jobs and start a yogurt brand. Elan has been making yogurt in her apartment, and it's more probiotic than the average yogurt." There was something about these gals - I knew they were going to be special.
Talk me through your process. What is your first protocol when there are no references to start from?
It always starts really broad and I ask the founders the heavy-hitting questions: Why does this need to exist? Who’s going to care? Who are we targeting? Why would they choose this over a competitor? What is the overall vision? What is the story? What’s the purpose? What do you care about for the product and the company at large?
So we get into the positioning so we can carve out space for it - in this case Sourmilk is trying to build in a very crowded space - how the hell are we going to stand out against billion-dollar brands? So we talk A LOT about brand strategy and figure out where we want to go and, almost more importantly, where we don’t want to go with it.
Luckily, Elan and Kiki are the consumers of their own product, which oftentimes is what I tell founders when I'm working with them. I say, "You have to be the one that's championing your own product. No one else is gonna sing your name from the rooftops, so you might as well be the one that loves your product the most." The brand has to be an extension of them.
What have you noticed about how people talk about the packaging that you perhaps wouldn't have predicted?
I hear a lot of talk about how much it stands out in the yogurt space, which I am super proud of! We chose that bright blue that you can see from down the aisle, and the blobby font that almost looks like it’s written in yogurt.The thing that always takes people by surprise is, of course, the name - SOURMILK is so polarizing. But it’s smart as hell, they did a great job with that name. So when it came time to create the visuals around Sourmilk, I wanted to make sure we gave it an approachable visual identity that makes people feel like it’s for them even with a crazy name.
Is CPG packaging becoming too similar?
I definitely think that there's still so much room for surprise in CPG. That said - each category has an unspoken formula especially with packaging design. Some categories like candy or ice cream you wanna see the flavor represented in imagery on the front. With beverage it’s all about color-forward flavor indicators. The last thing you want to do is confuse the consumer when they see your product on shelf for the first time.
I think there's still a lot of room to make things feel fresh. It kind of goes with the times and the trends. People can definitely take inspiration from trends going on right now, but then five years from now, the trends are gonna be different.
There's always gonna be a cycle of sameness, and there's gonna be a cycle of freshness that goes along with that. It just keeps going. I'm always trying to find freshness.
If you were to pull up a percentage, how many projects are you called in on when the product is literally being formulated and the name is being formulated, versus when someone already has a product and wants to rebrand?
Right now, I would say it's kind of 50/50.
50% building brands from scratch which is quite literally my passion
50% helping brands expand to new places whether that’s going from direct-to-consumer to their first retail store, or going from indie store to national retailers like Target, Costco, Sprouts, Walmart…
What do you get more fulfilment out of? Something from scratch or that refining work?
It changes, but right now my fulfilment definitely comes from seeing brands in their early stages expanding into bigger retailers or national launches. I love designing packaging for retail, which is hilarious to say, but the fulfilment of seeing my computer files turn into a physical product that lands on the shelves of major retailers is kind of unmatched. It's a high for sure.
What is that line between your personal taste being an asset and when it becomes a limitation?
For sure. I am very lucky to have had a good amount of ego death in the world of creativity early in my career. I’m always trying to push the envelope and of course I try to sell the most unique idea I can come up with to my clients and founders of these brands. But some people just need sans serif type for their logo, and, hey, it’s their thing, I’m not going to argue. If that's what they really want, then that's what they're gonna get!
Were there any design rules that you broke for Sourmilk?
I’m so grateful that Kiki and Elan were down to go against the grain - there’s a lot of white background brand identities in the yogurt space. We’re definitely breaking the norms of the design of the yogurt aisle - but not so much that people get confused. It’s all about balance.
Who are some other designers on your radar, or some brands on your radar, where you think kudos is due?
Oh my goodness, so many. One of the first CPG beverage designs that ever really stuck out to me was one called Kin, I was so fascinated by how beautiful a beverage brand could be. Kinda changed everything for me.
So obviously I researched the agency behind it, which is Center, a branding agency based here in New York. I'm lucky now to call the founder, Alex, a friend. Center Design has done some really great stuff, from KIN Euphorics to Ayoh Mayo, which is such a fun and playful brand identity, along with Bero, which already feels like a legacy beer brand.
Pulp & Wire is a really great agency that I've been looking at recently too.
A packaging re-design that really inspired me recently is gonna surprise people, but it's Bob's Red Mill, they do grains and flours and mixes. They just did a rebrand, and I was like, "Wow, that is so good." Bob’s has been around forever and I love seeing them bring in color blocking, that subtle barn on the front, and a cleaned up new logo … really inspired me and I love that it’s such an old-school brand.
I'm working on a beef jerky brand right now, and I think the founders are kind of sick of me talking about it. They're like, "Okay, we get it. It's good."
I'm like, "No, you guys don't understand. This is so unexpectedly good.”
It was the first major packaging update since the '90s, so it had to be something big, right?
Yeah I guess it had to be something big. I mean, I just love this colour-blocking effect. That is soooo my vibe. It’s what we've done with Sourmilk. It's so what I've done with other brands, and it just never ceases to feel really satisfying. On pack, on shelf, on website. It's so good. So satisfying.
You've been running Charlotte Cooper Creative since 2023. Are you surprised at how it's evolved?
I really am. It’s crazy to feel the evolution and years of experience in my work and also in how I run the agency now. Finding my value and finding my confidence and recognising myself as someone who's actually kind of impressive in the space, it’s taken time. Honestly, it wasn't until literally this year that I was like, "Oh, I’m actually really good at this and I totally know what I'm doing" I *feel* the experience that I have now.
Do you think you'd eventually want to hire and get a studio?
Oh yeah. I’ve got big plans to hire on full-time designers and creatives, definitely want an office. A year from now CCC is going to look very different/
I do eventually see myself changing the name, which haunts me but I want to remove my full legal name from the name of the agency.
What are your thoughts on AI?
It really helps with the back end of the business, especially as someone who just wants to focus on the work, actually spending hours deep in the Adobe programs.
I love it as a tool - how deep can I go with the references I’m thinking about? How can I refine an idea to make sense to an audience that I’m not super familiar with. I’m often using it for research.
It’s hard for me to get on board with using it for actual design… I’m such a graphic design nerd and I'm so grateful that I grew up spending hours of my life figuring out Photoshop, Illustrator, InDesign and the Adobe suite. Thanks to those years I have this incredible skill and an understanding of the medium that let’s me bring ideas to life. I’m not sure what learning those programs looks like now with AI in the mix - is the knowledge as deep? Or is the knowledge of how to get AI to create for you the real skill now? We’ll see I guess.
Where do you go for inspiration?
Definitely the world around me. I'm so aware of everything going on around me at all times. Whether it's the people... In New York City especially, it's everywhere. The people in the streets, the signage, the fashion. I'm looking around at what the ads are saying in the subway and what’s going on on instagram constantly.
I talk to my mother, actually, a lot. She’s always up on some new trend and often times ahead of them… So I definitely talk to her a lot about inspo.
Obviously travel is a big source of inspiration - Foreign cities typically are really inspiring to me. It's just so fun to get out of the familiar. I think you can definitely find inspiration in being out of your comfort zone.
What's in your grocery basket right now?
I love dissociating at Whole Foods. I blink and all of a sudden there’s some freaky stuff in my basket… but right now I’m loving Lentiful. It's instant lentils in a little container. There's tons of protein, well-balanced fiber, & it’s pretty low-calorie. They do a great job with their seasonings. You can tell they put a lot of effort into their flavors.
There's another product that no one is talking about, it’s a frozen breakfast sandwich called Mason Dixie. If you want an easy, yummy, well-balanced, nutritious little breakfast sandwich at home, Mason Dixie is for you. And they’re women owned!
When I’m going out with friends or having a fun friday I always reach for Goldilocks. It's very fun, New York City party girl vibe. They have a blackberry that’s my favorite. They also have a really yummy coffee-tini. And it’s all like 5% so not super high ABV.











